Tag: Jonathan Raskin


What About Meaning?

Hanfstengel

Several writers have presented exciting new ideas for classifying and diagnosing human problems. Peter Kinderman, for instance, has proposed a “problem list and formulation” approach in which clinicians list however many presenting problems a client brings to session. Jeffrey Rubin has put forward ideas for a “Classification and Statistical Manual of Mental Health Concerns,” shifting… Read more »

Speaking in Code

Rosetta_Stone

The recent publication of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) has brought several new disorders into the public consciousness while eliminating some old ones. As just two examples, Disruptive Mood Dysregulation disorder is in, but Asperger’s is out. The often-overlooked irony is that when it comes to diagnostic codes—the numeric or alphanumeric… Read more »

Can Evolutionary Theory Help Us Define Mental Disorder?

Dover_elevator_passenger_controls_283_floors2920wiki

Editor’s Note: Jerome Wakefield gave a presentation on his harmful dysfunction approach to defining mental disorders at SUNY New Paltz in March 2011. Jonathan Raskin served as discussant, and his response, reproduced here, remains highly relevant in light of ongoing debates about how the upcoming DSM-5 should define mental disorder. Video of both Dr. Wakefield’s… Read more »

Defining Mental Disorder, DSM-5 Style

Artificial.intelligence20wiki

What is a mental disorder? This is a question the American Psychiatric Association (2012) has been contemplating as it prepares the DSM-5, the soon-to-be-published revision of its Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. The DSM-5 development website proposes the following new definition of mental disorder (APA, 2012): A behavioral or psychological syndrome or pattern… Read more »

For the new DSM’s consideration: “Pathologizing Personality Disorder.”

DSMs201-4

Photo by Steve Balt Proposed diagnostic criteria for a new mental disorder for potential inclusion in the next version of the DSM: 309.XX Pathologizing Personality Disorder A.  Marked tendency to see other people’s behavior as disordered and/or disturbing. B.  Presence of at least four of the following: (1) history of studying psychiatry and/or participating in psychiatric… Read more »

Does Going to a Psychotherapist Mean Youêre Mentally Ill?

Burton20melancholie20frontispiece_0

Your insurance company wants you to read this Does going to a psychotherapist mean you’re mentally ill? If you want it paid for by your health insurance, then the answer is yes. Why? Because in order to get paid, your therapist is required to diagnose you with a mental disorder. Another way to think about… Read more »